February 1, 2023

A jury deliberated for lower than 40 minutes Tuesday earlier than acquitting a Newport Information man of manslaughter expenses introduced after he killed a person in a struggle exterior a house 5 years in the past.

The 12-member jury discovered Michael Robert Paparelli not responsible of voluntary manslaughter within the Nov. 24, 2017 slaying of 34-year-old Corey David Hunter.

Paparelli, who was out on bond for years pending trial, hugged his attorneys, Cathy Krinick and Christina James, in emotional embraces after the decision capped the weeklong trial.







Michael Robert Paparelli, 47, was charged with voluntary manslaughter in the shooting death of Corey David Hunter on Nov. 24, 2017.

Michael Robert Paparelli, 47, was charged with voluntary manslaughter within the capturing loss of life of Corey David Hunter on Nov. 24, 2017.










Corey David Hunter

Corey David Hunter




“It’s been an extended street, and I’m simply glad it’s come to its conclusion,” Paparelli informed the Day by day Press after the listening to. “It’s been tough for the entire households, for everyone.”

Throughout closing arguments Tuesday, Newport Information prosecutors conceded Hunter was “the preliminary aggressor” within the struggle, however stated Paparelli acted unlawfully in capturing Hunter even after he turned and ran from the gunshots.

Individuals are additionally studying…

  • Here is your Richmond Cheesy Lights record for 2022 🎄🎁
  • Jury awards $4 million in Virginia jail loss of life case
  • Varina’s Kaveion Keys, the Richmond space’s prime recruit within the Class of 2023, commits to Penn State
  • 1 critically wounded in Henrico County capturing
  • Stephen ‘tWitch’ Boss reportedly ‘left suicide notice’, Rihanna shares TikTok of child boy, and extra celeb information
  • Virginia from Above: Elimination of A.P. Hill statue
  • Voting can be quick, counting sluggish in 4th District Democratic major
  • Bagby drops out of congressional race and endorses McClellan
  • Colette McEachin backs McClellan, says district ‘deserves higher’ than Morrissey
  • ‘Do not ask me in regards to the referees’: Commanders furious after late-game officiating results in loss to Giants
  • The ultimate highschool soccer Prime 10 of 2022
  • ‘Jinks’ Holton, former Virginia first woman, advocate for youngsters, dies at 97
  • McClellan, Morrissey make final push in chaotic Democratic major
  • Man fatally struck by Amtrak practice in Henrico County
  • 3 significantly damage in horse-drawn carriage crash in Richmond County

A state post-mortem exhibits Hunter was shot 5 occasions — twice within the palms and 3 times within the again. Trial proof confirmed he was seemingly shot from greater than two ft away.

“It’s not self-defense to shoot a fleeing particular person when he’s operating away — and to shoot him within the again,” Newport Information prosecutor Melissa Freudenberg stated in her closing argument.

However Krinick contended the capturing was clearly self-defense, saying Paparelli was in his entrance yard when “a stranger he’s by no means seen … begins attacking.” He had nowhere else to show, she asserted.

“If this isn’t self-defense, what’s?” Krinick requested. “He reacted primarily based on intuition … It was an affordable response to what was being carried out to him.”

In a 911 name instantly after the capturing, a extremely distraught Paparelli informed a police dispatcher that Hunter “attacked me” and “sucker punched me.” He urged the dispatcher a number of occasions to ship an ambulance as quickly as attainable.

The occasions that led to Hunter’s loss of life had been set in movement when Paparelli’s girlfriend known as a pal in hysterics, saying Paparelli had assaulted her within the couple’s house on Prince William Street.

The pal, Stefani Gavalya, and Hunter, a York County man she’d not too long ago begun relationship, instantly went to Paparelli’s home. Whereas the 2 girls knew one another effectively, the 2 males had by no means beforehand met.

Hunter was closely intoxicated when he arrived on the house, trial proof exhibits.

The prosecution’s case was broken by a sequence of textual content messages exchanged between Hunter and a pal as he waited in his pickup exterior Paparelli’s house. Hunter informed the pal he was there to beat up an armed man who had hit a lady — however that he’d hit the person earlier than he might draw his gun.

After these texts got here to mild earlier within the case, the prosecution lowered the cost in opposition to Paparelli from second-degree homicide to manslaughter.

Paparelli wasn’t house after they arrived, however returned after his girlfriend known as to inform him she wanted their daughter’s automobile seat from his truck.

A fistfight between the lads started shortly thereafter, with witnesses saying Paparelli fired the photographs in fast succession about 10 seconds into the altercation.

“They shot me, I’m lifeless,” Hunter stated, earlier than collapsing close to a roadway about 16 ft away.

Paparelli ran inside and received his cellphone to name 911. Witnesses stated he additionally received towels to attempt to staunch Hunter’s wounds, and likewise used a blood clotting resolution on them. However these efforts didn’t work, and Hunter died en path to a hospital.

“These are the actions of an harmless man, women and gents,” Krinick informed jurors of Paparelli attempting to save lots of Hunter’s life.

Courtroom data say Paparelli has 4 kids and was working in development on the time of the 2017 slaying. Hunter, for his half, was the daddy of a then 9-year-old son. He labored at 757 Boxing Membership in Newport Information, as a promoter for beginner Combined Martial Arts occasions.

After Tuesday’s verdict, Krinick stated the jury’s deliberation time of about 40 minutes was among the many shortest she will recall in a profession spanning greater than 4 many years. “We’ve all the time thought it was self-defense, however you by no means know till you hear it from the jury,” she stated.

Other than the manslaughter verdict, Paparelli was additionally acquitted of a second cost of utilizing a gun in a felony. He would have confronted as much as 13 years behind bars if convicted on each counts.

One among Paparelli’s neighbors, Brian Hartley, stated he was relieved on the jury’s choice. “I’m glad that the reality was informed, and his innocence was confirmed,” he stated.

Freudenberg and one other Newport Information prosecutor, Andrea Booden, declined to touch upon the decision.

However Hunter’s household stated they had been “heartbroken and disenchanted.” They contended the weeklong trial targeted too closely on Hunter’s previous and never sufficient on the preliminary beating case that drew him and his girlfriend to the Denbigh house within the first place.

Hunter’s former mother-in-law, Sherry Thacker, stated Hunter was a fantastic father to his now-14-year-old son Jayden, drew individuals to him with an outgoing and pleasant persona, and “will dwell in our hearts ceaselessly.”

“We’ve lived this for 5 years,” Thacker stated. “All the pieces has been about this case … And I informed (Jayden) we’re going to take a deep breath, and we’re going to maneuver on, and tomorrow it’s going to be a brand new day.”

Peter Dujardin, 757-247-4749, pdujardin@dailypress.com